top of page

OPINION: "Dear John" Letters Don't Cut It Anymore

Judd Hirsch Reading a "Dear John" Letter in the 1980's NBC Sitcom Dear John

We've all seen them, those open letters penned by mayors, MLAs/MPPs/MHAs, or MPs, demanding immediate action on various issues from other levels of government. They flood our social media feeds, aiming to garner attention and rally support.

At first, they may have seemed like a necessary tool in the municipal arsenal, but as time passes, they're becoming increasingly overplayed and well frakly underwhelming.

Consider the recent "Dear John" letter from the Mayor of Edmonton to Premier Danielle Smith, pleading for increased funding for the city. A decade or two ago, such a move might have stirred attention and catalyzed action. But in today's fast-paced, 15 minute news cycle, it's akin to a fleeting moment, barely registering before it's buried beneath the next headline.

Municipal leaders across Canada are grappling with the diminishing impact of traditional advocacy methods. The landscape has shifted, and what once commanded attention now struggles to penetrate the public consciousness. Even well-orchestrated campaigns during provincial elections, like Alberta Municipalities' "Think Alberta, Vote Local," or the Association of Manitoba Municipalities' "Let's Grow Manitoba Together!" fail to resonate as they should.

The problem runs deeper than mere communication strategies; it's symptomatic of a broader disconnect between municipal issues and public engagement. While municipal leaders earnestly tackle community concerns, the populace seems increasingly disinterested, caught up in partisan squabbles rather than substantive dialogue.

For too long, municipalities have relied on outdated methods to amplify their voices. Open letters may have served a purpose in the past, but in 2024, they're an insufficient means of effecting change. It's time for municipal leaders to assume a more proactive role, to be the grown-ups in the room, and invite federal and provincial counterparts to the table.

The Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM) has been calling for meaningful dialogue between all levels of government, yet this call has largely fallen on deaf ears. It's incumbent upon municipalities to take charge, to compel federal and provincial leaders to engage in the conversations that matter.

The current state of affairs is untenable. The incessant bickering and lack of constructive engagement between levels of government undermine effective governance.

If the Premier's and the Prime Minister continue down this path, they may find themselves on the receiving end of a "Dear John" letter from municipalities, seeking alternative avenues for partnership.

As the days pass and issues remain unaddressed, municipalities must find new ways to capture public attention and ensure their voices are heard. Whether through innovative communication strategies or assertive advocacy efforts, municipalities must adapt to the evolving landscape of governance.

Ultimately, the success of municipal governance hinges on collaborative, constructive relationships between all levels of government. It's time for federal and provincial leaders to set aside petty differences and prioritize the needs of the communities they serve.

The era of open letters may be waning, but the imperative for effective governance remains as strong as ever.


bottom of page